Gradle takes ages to complete


(Russel Winder) #1

On Debian Unstable, when issuing a gradle command on the Bash command line, for example:

|> gradle clean :clean

BUILD SUCCESSFUL

Total time: 3.587 secs

it then takes 4 or 5 seconds for the command to complete and the Bash prompt to appear. This has to be seen as a bug.


(Peter Niederwieser) #2

3.5 seconds doesn’t seem out of the world; I get 2.5 seconds on my brand-new Mac. To avoid the startup overhead, enable the Gradle daemon.


(Russel Winder) #3

You miss my point. Gradle doing things for 3.5 seconds and then printing a message is fine, per se. Gradle then delaying a further 4 or 5 seconds before terminating after printing the the message is unacceptable. If there is more to be done after the build is complete then Gradle should not be printing a message that is untruthful, it should delay printing the message and the timing till the very end and be printing 7 seconds after it is all done.

I don’t want daemons, I want a truthful report.

This is about good UI and UX nothing more.


(Peter Niederwieser) #4

Can you try again with increased memory settings? Where is the time spent according to ‘top’? I doubt that Gradle is actively doing something here.


(Russel Winder) #5

htop reports using 400% of my CPU during the actual cleaning and 200% of my CPU in the waiting period after completion. I am not sure of how to collect proper data that can be useful.

I would have thought the default memory setting would be fine. Anyway this is JDK 8 which has the G1 GC and so should cope.


(Peter Niederwieser) #6

Can you tell what the user/system CPU time ratio is for the waiting period? Does the problem also occur for a “hello world” build? Can you try with a released version of JDK7? Maybe Debian unstable is having a bad day? :slight_smile:


(Russel Winder) #7

With JDK 8:

|> time gradle clean :clean UP-TO-DATE

BUILD SUCCESSFUL

Total time: 2.767 secs

real 0m8.349s user 0m14.069s sys 0m0.336s

With JDK7

|> (export JAVA_HOME=$HOME/lib.Linux.x86_64/JDK7 ; time gradle clean) :clean UP-TO-DATE

BUILD SUCCESSFUL

Total time: 3.327 secs

real 0m3.443s user 0m6.348s sys 0m0.272s

So this is clearly either:

  1. JDK8 as released by Oracle is problematic; or 2) Gradle is failing under JDK8